Emma's Forbidden Cravings - Cheating Girlfriend Erotica - Part 2

The bass was a living thing—throbbing, pulsing, vibrating through the floorboards of Sigma Chi house and into Emma Thompson's chest like a second heartbeat. It was Saturday night, three weeks after she'd bent over Marcus Chen's desk and let him claim her in ways that still haunted her dreams, and Emma was learning that betrayal had a taste. It was coppery and sweet, like blood and candy mixed together, coating her tongue every time she looked at Jake's unsuspecting face.

"Having fun, babe?" Jake shouted over the music, his hand warm and possessive on the small of her back.

Emma forced a smile, leaning into his touch even as her eyes scanned the crowded room. The fraternity house was a monument to excess—red plastic cups littered every surface, the air thick with the competing scents of cheap beer, sweat, and expensive cologne. Bodies pressed together in the dim light, grinding to the beat, and somewhere above them, someone was already vomiting off a balcony.

"Yeah," she lied, the word feeling natural now, practiced. "This is great."

Jake's smile was genuine, delighted that she was enjoying herself. He'd been trying to get her to come to one of these parties since freshman year, but Emma had always demurred, preferring quiet movie nights or dinner dates. She'd told herself it was because frat parties were loud and messy and beneath her. The truth was, she'd been afraid of what might happen if she let herself get swept up in the chaos.

Now she knew. Now she was counting the minutes until she could find an excuse to slip away.

"Tyler said he'd save us some of the good stuff," Jake said, nodding toward the kitchen where their friend was ostensibly mixing drinks. "Want me to grab you something?"

Emma's pulse kicked up a notch. This was it. Her opening. "Actually, I need to use the bathroom first. The line downstairs was crazy—I'm going to check upstairs."

"Want me to come with you?" Jake asked, ever the gentleman, ever the protector.

"No, it's fine." Emma pressed a quick kiss to his cheek, tasting the familiar salt of his skin. "Get us drinks. I'll meet you by the pong table in ten?"

"Ten minutes," Jake agreed, squeezing her hand before releasing her. "Don't get lost in this maze. These houses are like prisons."

Emma laughed, the sound hollow even to her own ears. "I'll be careful."

She turned and melted into the crowd, her heart hammering against her ribs. She wasn't going to the bathroom. Not really. She was going to find him—the reason she'd agreed to come to this stupid party in the first place, the reason she'd spent an extra twenty minutes that morning choosing the perfect underwear, the reason she couldn't seem to stop sabotaging the best relationship she'd ever had.

His name was Caleb Jennings, and he'd been a mistake from the moment Emma laid eyes on him.

They'd met three days ago at the campus gym, completely by accident. Emma had been on the elliptical, minding her own business, when he'd appeared in the reflection of the mirror—six-foot-four of solid muscle wrapped in a tank top that should have been illegal. He was the star tight end for Westfield's football team, a senior with NFL scouts already circling, and he'd had the kind of face that belonged on billboards: chiseled jaw, piercing blue eyes, and a smile that promised trouble.

Emma had tried to look away. She'd tried to focus on her workout, on her breathing, on anything but the way his sweat-slicked muscles gleamed under the fluorescent lights.

But then he'd caught her staring. And instead of looking away embarrassed, he'd walked right up to her machine, leaned in close enough that she could smell the testosterone and exertion rolling off him in waves, and said, "You keep looking at me like that, sweetheart, and I'm going to have to do something about it."

She should have mentioned Jake. Should have held up her hand, shown him the promise ring, told him she was taken.

Instead, she'd said, "Like what?"

Caleb's smile had been slow and predatory. "Like bend you over the weight bench and fuck you until you forget your own name."

Emma had nearly fallen off the elliptical. The words were crude, disrespectful, exactly the kind of thing that should have offended her. Instead, she'd felt that familiar heat pooling between her legs—that dangerous, addictive warmth that had started with Marcus and seemed to be growing stronger every day.

"I have a boyfriend," she'd whispered, as if that explained anything.

"I don't care," Caleb had replied, his eyes dropping to her mouth. "Sigma Chi party Saturday. Wear something I can tear off you. I'll find you."

He'd walked away without another word, leaving Emma panting and flushed and absolutely certain she wouldn't show up.

But here she was. And there he was.

Emma spotted him across the crowded living room, leaning against the wall with a red cup in his hand, surrounded by teammates and adoring freshman girls. He was even more imposing in civilian clothes—jeans that hung low on his hips, a white t-shirt that strained against his chest, and tattoos snaking up his arms that she'd somehow missed at the gym. He looked like sin incarnate, like every bad decision Emma had ever been too smart to make.

Their eyes met across the room, and Emma felt the impact like a physical blow. Caleb's gaze was heated, hungry, stripping her bare from twenty feet away. He raised his cup in a silent toast, his lips curving in a smile that said he knew exactly why she was here.

Emma's phone buzzed in her pocket—a text from Jake.

Jake: Got our drinks. Where are you?

She didn't answer. She couldn't answer. Because Caleb was moving toward her now, cutting through the crowd with the easy confidence of someone who'd never been told no in his life, and Emma was frozen, caught between the girl she was supposed to be and the woman she was becoming.

"Emma Thompson," Caleb said when he reached her, his voice a rumble she felt in her bones. "I wasn't sure you'd come."

"I wasn't sure either," she admitted, her voice barely audible over the music.

Caleb's hand found her waist, his thumb brushing the strip of bare skin where her crop top met her skirt. "Your boyfriend here?"

"Downstairs," Emma breathed. "Getting drinks."

Caleb's smile widened, showing teeth. "Perfect. Upstairs. Third door on the left. Bathroom. Two minutes." He leaned down, his lips brushing her ear, his breath hot against her skin. "And Emma? Don't wear anything under that skirt. I want you ready for me."

He was gone before she could respond, disappearing back into the crowd, leaving Emma trembling and soaked through her panties.

She should go back to Jake. Should find him, grab his hand, and drag him out of this house and back to the safety of their dorm room. She should delete Caleb's number—she'd saved it that day at the gym, telling herself it was just in case, just for emergencies—and block Marcus too, and go to therapy, and figure out why she was determined to destroy her own happiness.

Instead, Emma Thompson, perfect girlfriend and secret sinner, walked up the stairs.

The third floor hallway was quieter, the music muffled by closed doors and thick walls. Emma's heels clicked against the hardwood as she walked, each step feeling like a countdown to something inevitable. Her hands were shaking as she reached the door Caleb had indicated—a small bathroom tucked at the end of the hall, barely large enough for a toilet and a sink.

The door was unlocked. She pushed it open and stepped inside.

Caleb was already there, leaning against the sink, his arms crossed over his massive chest. He'd locked the door behind him—she heard the click as he secured the deadbolt—and suddenly the small space felt even smaller, filled with his presence and her racing heartbeat.

"Close call," he said, his eyes roaming over her body with undisguised hunger. "I wasn't sure you'd have the guts."

"I shouldn't be here," Emma whispered, even as she stepped further into the room.

"No," Caleb agreed, pushing off the sink and closing the distance between them. "You shouldn't. You should be downstairs with your perfect boyfriend, drinking whatever fruity shit he bought you, thinking about your perfect future." He reached out, his hand cupping her jaw, his thumb pressing against her lower lip. "But you're not, are you? You're here. With me. Because you can't stop thinking about what it would feel like to get fucked by someone who actually knows what he's doing."

Emma's breath hitched. "Caleb—"

"Take them off." His voice was a command, rough and absolute. "The panties. Take them off and give them to me."

Emma should have been offended. Should have slapped him, stormed out, told him to go to hell. Instead, she found her hands moving to the waistband of her skirt, hooking her thumbs in the lace of her thong, and sliding it down her legs.

The air in the bathroom was cool against her bare skin, making her shiver. She stepped out of the panties, the delicate fabric pooled around her ankles, and reached down to retrieve them. Caleb's hand shot out, stopping her.

"Leave them," he ordered. "Kick them off."

Emma did as she was told, stepping out of the underwear and leaving it on the floor. Caleb's gaze dropped to her exposed pussy, his eyes darkening with lust.

"Fuck," he groaned. "You're already wet, aren't you? Just from me telling you what to do. From knowing you're about to get fucked while your boyfriend waits downstairs like a chump."

"Please," Emma whimpered, the word escaping before she could stop it. "Please, Caleb, I can't—"

"Can't what?" He crowded her against the wall, his massive frame pinning her in place, his erection hard and insistent against her stomach. "Can't wait? Can't stand how much you want this?" His hand dropped between her legs, his fingers finding her wetness and sliding through it with obscene ease. "Jesus, Emma. You're fucking drenched. This is what you need, isn't it? A big cock to fill this tight little pussy. Someone to treat you like the dirty slut you are."

Emma's head fell back against the wall, her eyes squeezing shut as his fingers worked her. He was rougher than Marcus had been—less refined, more animalistic—and the contrast sent sparks of pleasure shooting through her body. She could hear the party continuing outside, the bass still thumping, voices laughing and shouting just feet away from where she was being fingered by a man who wasn't her boyfriend.

"Look at me," Caleb commanded, his fingers stilling. "Open your eyes and look at me while I fuck you with my hand. I want to see your face when you come for me."

Emma forced her eyes open, meeting his gaze. Caleb's expression was fierce, predatory, completely focused on her pleasure in a way that made her feel simultaneously objectified and worshipped. He resumed his movements, two thick fingers pushing inside her while his thumb worked her clit in tight, merciless circles.

"That's it," he growled. "Take it. Take my fingers like you're going to take my cock. Fuck, you're tight. Is your boyfriend this big? Does he stretch you like this?"

"No," Emma gasped, her hips bucking against his hand. "Never—he's never—"

"Never what?" Caleb's fingers curled, finding that spot inside her that made her see stars. "Never fucked you properly? Never made you scream? Never made you feel like a woman instead of a princess?"

"Never," Emma sobbed, the truth tearing out of her. "He's never—oh God, Caleb, please—"

"Please what?" He was relentless, his hand working her with mechanical precision, driving her toward the edge with brutal efficiency. "Please make you come? Please fuck you? Please ruin you for that vanilla piece of shit downstairs?"

"All of it," Emma begged, her hands clutching at his shoulders, her nails digging into the hard muscle. "Please, Caleb, I need you inside me, I can't wait anymore—"

Caleb's fingers withdrew suddenly, leaving her empty and aching. Emma cried out at the loss, but before she could protest, he was lifting her, his hands under her thighs, pinning her against the wall with his body.

"Wrap your legs around me," he ordered, and Emma complied instantly, locking her ankles behind his back. She could feel his cock, hard and thick and straining against his jeans, pressing against her entrance. "You want this? You want me to fuck you raw in this bathroom while your boyfriend waits for you?"

"Yes," Emma gasped, her eyes rolling back as she felt him positioning himself. "Yes, please, fuck me, Caleb, please—"

He drove into her with one brutal thrust that tore a scream from her throat—a scream she quickly muffled by biting down on his shoulder. Caleb was huge, thicker than Marcus, stretching her impossibly wide as he bottomed out inside her with a groan that vibrated through his chest.

"Fuck," he gritted out, his forehead dropping to hers. "Fuck, Emma, you're so fucking tight. So fucking perfect. This is what you needed, isn't it? This is what you've been craving."

"Yes," Emma sobbed, her body already adjusting to his size, her muscles clenching around him involuntarily. "Yes, don't stop, please don't stop—"

Caleb didn't stop. He set a brutal pace, pulling out and slamming back into her with enough force to rattle the mirror on the wall. The bathroom was small, cramped, the air hot and humid with their combined exertion, and every thrust drove Emma harder against the tiles, the cool ceramic a stark contrast to the heat of his body.

"You're taking it so well," Caleb groaned, his hips snapping forward, his hands gripping her ass hard enough to leave bruises. "Such a good girl for me. Such a dirty little cheater. Does he know what you're doing right now? Does he know his perfect girlfriend is getting railed in a frat house bathroom?"

"No," Emma gasped, her head thrashing from side to side. "He doesn't—he can't—oh God, Caleb, harder—"

"You want it harder?" Caleb laughed, a dark, dangerous sound. "You want me to fuck you so hard you won't be able to walk back to him? Is that what you want, Emma? You want to go back to your boyfriend with my cum dripping down your legs?"

The words should have disgusted her. Instead, they sent her spiraling toward the edge, her orgasm building with terrifying speed. "Yes," she choked out. "Yes, I want it, please, Caleb, I'm so close—"

"Not yet," Caleb growled, his hand tangling in her hair and pulling her head back, exposing her throat. "You don't come until I say you can. You don't get to enjoy this until I'm done using you."

He shifted his angle, hitting a spot inside her that made her vision blur, and Emma cried out, her body trembling on the precipice of release. She could hear voices in the hallway now—people walking past the door, laughing, talking, completely unaware of what was happening just feet away from them. The risk of discovery sent electric shocks of arousal through her, making every sensation sharper, every thrust more intense.

"Please," she begged, tears streaming down her face, her body shaking with the effort of holding back her orgasm. "Please, Caleb, I can't—I need to—"

"Now," he commanded, his free hand finding her clit and pinching hard. "Come for me now, Emma. Come on my cock like the filthy cheating slut you are."

The orgasm crashed over her with the force of a tsunami, her body convulsing around him as she bit down on his shoulder to muffle her screams. Wave after wave of pleasure rolled through her, obliterating every coherent thought, every lingering shred of guilt or hesitation. She was nothing but sensation, nothing but the tight coil of release unraveling inside her, nothing but Caleb's cock filling her, claiming her, marking her as his.

"Fuck, that's it," Caleb groaned, his rhythm faltering as her muscles milked him. "Fuck, you're squeezing me so tight. I'm gonna—fuck, Emma, I'm gonna fill you up. I'm gonna cum deep inside this cheating pussy, and you're gonna take it all. You're gonna go back to him with my load inside you, aren't you? You're gonna let him kiss you and touch you and never know that another man's cum is still warm in his girlfriend's cunt."

"Yes," Emma sobbed, her body still spasming with aftershocks. "Yes, please, cum in me, Caleb, I want it, I need it—"

With a final, brutal thrust and a roar that he muffled against her neck, Caleb came, his cock pulsing inside her as he emptied himself in thick, hot spurts. Emma felt every twitch, every pulse, the obscene warmth of his release filling her and mixing with her own arousal. He kept her pinned against the wall, his hips jerking involuntarily as he rode out his orgasm, his breathing ragged against her skin.

For a long moment, they stayed like that—joined, panting, the air thick with the scent of sex and sweat and betrayal. Emma's legs were shaking, her body spent and marked and thoroughly used. She could feel Caleb's cum already beginning to leak out of her, trickling down her thighs, and the filthy reality of what she'd just done sent a fresh wave of arousal through her exhausted body.

"Fuck," Caleb breathed, his forehead resting against hers. "That was... fuck, Emma. That was incredible."

Emma couldn't speak. Her throat was raw from holding back screams, her mind slowly returning to her body, reality creeping back in like cold water. She'd just let a stranger cum inside her. She'd just cheated on Jake—again—with no protection, no thought for consequences, no care for the future she'd been planning for years.

And she wanted to do it again.

Caleb slowly lowered her to the ground, his cock sliding out of her with a wet sound that made Emma's face flush. She swayed on her feet, her legs weak, and Caleb caught her, steadying her with a hand on her waist.

"You okay?" he asked, his voice softer now, almost tender.

Emma nodded, unable to meet his eyes. "I need to—my panties—"

"Leave them," Caleb said again, his hand tightening on her waist. "I want you to feel me dripping out of you. I want you to remember who you belong to when you're kissing him goodnight."

Emma shivered, the command sending a fresh jolt of heat through her core. She reached for her purse—she'd brought a small clutch instead of her usual bag—and pulled out a pack of tissues, cleaning herself as best she could while Caleb watched with dark, satisfied eyes.

"You should go," he said finally, zipping his jeans and adjusting his shirt. "Before he comes looking for you."

Emma's stomach twisted. Jake. She'd been up here for—she checked her phone—twenty-three minutes. Twenty-three minutes of hard, brutal fucking while her boyfriend waited downstairs with drinks in his hands.

"Emma." Caleb's voice was firm, commanding her attention. She looked up, meeting his gaze. "This isn't over. You understand? You're mine now. When I text you, you come. When I want you, you spread your legs. That's the deal."

Emma should have said no. Should have told him it was a one-time thing, a mistake, something that would never happen again.

Instead, she whispered, "I understand."

Caleb smiled, slow and predatory. "Good girl. Now fix your hair and go back to your boyfriend. And Emma?" He caught her wrist as she reached for the door, pulling her back for one last, brutal kiss that left her lips swollen and bruised. "Think about me tonight when he's inside you. Think about how much better this was."

Emma fled the bathroom before she could respond, her heart hammering, her body tender and marked and filled with another man's seed.

The hallway was crowded now, bodies pressing together as people moved between rooms. Emma navigated through them on autopilot, her mind racing, her body humming with a dangerous cocktail of satisfaction and panic. She could feel Caleb's cum inside her, warm and obscene, a constant reminder of what she'd just done.

She ducked into an empty bedroom and checked her reflection in the mirror on the back of the door. Her hair was tangled, her mascara slightly smudged, her lips swollen and red. She looked like a woman who'd just been thoroughly fucked—and she had twenty seconds to transform back into the perfect girlfriend before Jake saw her.

Emma ran her fingers through her hair, smoothing the wild strands. She wiped under her eyes, fixing her makeup as best she could. She pulled her skirt down—it had ridden up during the encounter, exposing more thigh than was decent—and adjusted her top. She looked... almost normal. Almost like the Emma Thompson who'd walked into this party an hour ago.

Almost.

There was something different in her eyes—a darkness, a hunger, a knowledge of her own capacity for betrayal that hadn't been there before. She looked like a woman who'd discovered a part of herself she couldn't control, a part that was growing stronger with every illicit touch.

Emma took a deep breath and stepped back into the hallway.